Comparative Analysis of Ukrainian and Russian Tradition of the Last Judgement Image in The 15th-18th Centuries

Keywords: icon, iconography, traditional iconography, Last Judgment

Abstract

Icons of the Last Judgment were widely spread in the Orthodox lands in the 15th century. Along with the monumental multi-subject icons of the Holy Passion, they were the main components of the artistic decoration of most of the churches, the most compositionally and ideologically complex works of icon painting. Iconographic innovations, first, of Russian masters, in association with the culture of the Orthodox state, gained the power of conviction of the original source.

Icons of the Last Judgment were most often placed on the western wall of the church above the door, to remind the parishioners once again, what was the meaning of life and what was waiting for everyone after death. The icons told about the Second Coming of Christ, salvation, and that everyone would respond before God for his or her life. They were huge in size, and their composition is one of the most difficult in iconography.

Traditional iconography of church painting (the icon painting canon) was a pledge and guarantee of dogmatic conformity and true icon painting. Common stylistic features were seen first of all, in a rich joyful coloring, in the tendency to simplify classical Byzantine patterns, and in the appearing of folk features in canonic composition.

To identify specific features in Ukrainian and Russian icons the content of the icons of the Last Judgment is disclosed in the paper and a comparative study of the resemblance of traditional moments of the Last Judgment iconography is made.

Thus, it is possible to say that certain semblance of the subject of Ukrainian and Russian icons was not a display of borrowing but mostly the evidence of the fact that both of those traditions were taken from a common source – Byzantine Orthodoxy. At the same time, Russian iconographic school was characterized by considerable isolationism, it was, so to say, «stewing in its own juice», distancing itself from the realities of life. Instead, Ukrainian iconography earlier receded from the Byzantine canon and was characterized by the borrowing of obvious Western European elements, as well as the traces of «folk origins» of the Last Judgment subject. Because of its maximum approach to the realities of Ukrainian social life, with all its problems and expectations, the subject of the Last Judgment was the most acceptable form of their representation.

References

Alekseev, A. (1998). Siuzhet «zmeia mytarstv» v kompozitsii russkikh ikon «Strashnogo suda».[The Plot of the «Serpent Ordeal» in the Composition of Russian Icons of the «Last Judgment»]. St. Petersburg [in Russian].

Bychkov, V.V. (2008). Fenomen ikony: Istoriia. Bogoslovie. Estetika. Iskusstvo [The Phenomenon of Icons: History. Theology. Aesthetics. Art]. Moscow: Ladomir [in Russian].

Berezhnaya, L. (2003). «Odesnuiu» i «oshuiuiu». Russkie i rusinskie pravoslavnye ikony «Strashnogo suda» na rubezhe epokh [«Odesnuiu» and «Oshuiuiu». Russian and Rusyn Orthodox Icons of the «Last Judgment» at the turn of the Epochs]. Moskva [in Russian].

Berezhnaya, L. & Himka, J. (2014). The World to Come Ukrainian Images of the Last Judgment. Cambridge [in English].

Buslaev, F.I. (1997). O russkoi ikone. Obshchie poniatiia o russkoi ikonopisi [About the Russian Icon. General Concepts of Russian Icon Painting]. Moskva [in Russian].

Buslaev, F.I. (1910). Izobrazhenie Strashnogo Suda po russkomu podlinniku XVII veka [Image of the Last Judgment on the Russian original of the XVII century]. St. Petersburg [in Russian].

Davydova, M. (n.d.). Ikony «Strashnogo suda» XVI-XVII vv. [Icons of the «Last Judgment» of the XVI-XVII centuries]. Retrieved from https://www.portal-slovo.ru/art/35909.php [in Ukrainian].

Kos, G. (2001). Strashnyi Sud v ukrainskomu mystetstvi [The Last Judgment in the Ukrainian Art]. Lviv [in Ukrainian].

Lepakhin, V.V. (2002). Ikona i ikonichnost [Icon and iconic]. Sankt-Peterburg [in Russian].

Ostashenko, E. (1998). Ikona «Strashnyi sud» iz Uspenskogo sobora Moskovskogo Kremlia i problemy stilia [Icon «Last Judgment» from the Assumption Cathedral of the Moscow Kremlin and the Problem of Style]. St. Petersburg [in Russian].

Pokrovskii, N.V. (1887). Strashnyi sud v pamiatnikakh vizantiiskogo i russkogo iskusstva [Last Judgment in the Monuments of Byzantine and Russian Art]. Odessa [in Russian].

Stepovyk, D. (2004). Istoriia ukrainskoi ikony X-XX stolit [A History of Ukrainian Icon in the 10th – 20th centuries]. Kyiv: Lybid [in Ukrainian].

Sventsіtska, V. (1998) Pro deiaki ikonohrafichni analohy ta paraleli v zobrazhenni Strashnoho sudu v zakhidnoukrainskykh ikonakh XV-XVI stolit ta ikonakh khudozhnykiv novhorodskoho kola [About Some Iconographic Analogs and Parallels in the Image of the Last Judgment in Western Ukrainian Icons from the 15th-16th centuries and the Icons of the Painters of the Novgorod Circle]. Lviv [in Ukrainian].

Tsodikovich, V. (1992). Semantika ikonografii «Strashnogo Suda» v russkom iskusstve XV-XVI vekov [The Semantics of the Last Judgment Iconography in Russian Art of the 15th-16th centuries] (Extended abstract of Candidate’s thesis). St. Petersburg [in Russian].

Published
01.07.2019
How to Cite
Grygorak, A. (2019). Comparative Analysis of Ukrainian and Russian Tradition of the Last Judgement Image in The 15th-18th Centuries. EMINAK: Scientific Quarterly Journal, (2(26), 9-19. https://doi.org/10.33782/eminak2019.2(26).284
Section
History of Ukraine