Causes of Conflicts between Parish Priests of Pyriatyn Protopopia in the second half of the 18th century

Keywords: conflict, Kyiv metropoly, parish, Pyriatyn protopopia, priest

Abstract

The conflict situations between parish priests of Pyriatyn protopopia in the second half of the 18th century are analyzed in the paper. The sources of the research are the materials of the Pyriatyn Clerical Board, which are stored in the State Archives of Poltava Region. Clerical Boards acted under the control of their spiritual leaders (protopopes) and they considered the disputes that arose among the parish clergy. We have found 58 cases that documented the situations when the priests had conflicts with each other.

They concern 72 priests, representing 32.3% of the total number of priests who patronized the protopopia in the studied period. Such rates indicate that conflicts were rather common in the life of the priests of Pyriatyn protopopia in the second half of the 18th century.

The vast majority of conflicts was connected with the «professional» activities of the pastors. They make up 72% of the total number of cases and include disputes regarding the performing of the sacraments and ceremonies to persons of not their parish, allocation of profits and the breach of succession during the divine service. In 41 of 58 cases, such as the performing of the sacraments and ceremonies to persons of not their parish (19 cases), allocation of church profits (18 cases), nonpayment of debt (3 cases), theft (1 case), priest's material claims to each other were concerned. Thus, we can conclude that the main source of controversies between the local priests were material claims arising during the performing of their pastoral duties.

The majority of conflicts were followed by the use of abusive vocabulary, and often physical violence. Beating and insults on the basis of personal animosity (21% of the total number of cases) were of common occurrence among the parish priests of the protopopia. As a rule, such conflicts arose during joint events involving priests of several churches. In the main, priests used the commonly used bad language, however, in some cases, quite real deeds are described.

References

Voloshyn, Yu. (2010). Konflikty v Poltavi druhoi polovyny XVIII st.: zmist, kharakter, mova [Conflicts in Poltava in the second half of the XVII century: content, character, language]. SOTSIUM. Almanakh sotsialnoi istorii, 9, 219-238 [in Ukrainian].

Darendorf, R. (1994). Elementy teorii sotsialnoho konflikta [Elements of the theory of social conflict]. Sotsis, 5, 142-147 [in Russian].

Dmytrenko, V.A. (2017). Oplata treb u rannomodernomu sotsiumi Hetmanshchyny: zakonodavche rehuliuvannia ta rehionalna praktyka [Payment for the request in the early modern society of the Hetmanate: legislative regulation and regional practice]. Molodyi vchenyi, 8.1, 9-13 [in Ukrainian].

Dubichynskyi, V.V. (2007). Suchasnyi tlumachnyi slovnyk ukrainskoi movy [Modern Dictionary of the Ukrainian Language]. Kharkiv: «SHKOLA» [in Ukrainian].

Horobets, V. (2016). Konflikt i vlada v ranniomoderniy Ukraini. Sotnyk novhorod-siverskyy proty hetmana Viyska Zaporozkoho, 1715-1722 [Conflict and Power in early Modern Ukraine. Sotnik Novgorod-Severskyvs Hetman of the Zaporozhian Army, 1715-1722]. Kyiv: Instytut istorii Ukrainy [in Ukrainian].

Prokopiuk, O. (2012). Kyivska mytropoliia: topohrafiia posviat. Rekonstruktsiia reiestru khramiv za vidomostiamy pro tserkovnosluzhyteliv (1780-1783 rr.) [Kiev Metropolitanate: Topography Will Dedicate. Reconstruction of the Register of Temples According to the Data on Church Servants (1780-1783)]. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].

Skochylias, I. (2010). Bratslavskyi terytorialnyi konflikt 1747-1754 rr.: pravovi arhumenty, eklezialni i sotsialni praktyky «vporiadkuvannia» heohrafichnoho prostoru ta istorychna pamiat [Bratslav Territorial Conflict of 1747-1754: Legal Arguments, Ecclesiastical and Social Practices of «Ordering» the Geographical Space and Historical Memory]. SOTSIUM. Almanakh sotsialnoi istorii, 9, 174-218 [in Ukrainian].

Starchenko, N. (2014). Chest, krov i rytoryka. Konflikt u shliakhetskomu seredovyshchi Volyni (druha polovyna XVI-XVII stolittia) [Honor, Blood and Rhetoric. Conflict in the Gentry’s Environment of Volyn (Second Half of the XVI-XVII centuries)]. Kyiv: Lauras [in Ukrainian].

Yaremenko, M. (2017). Pered vyklykamy unifikatsii ta dystsyplinuvannia: Kyivska pravoslavna mytropoliia u XVIII stolitti [Before the Challenges of Unification and Discipline: the Kiev Orthodox Metropolis in the XVIII century]. Lviv: Vydavnytstvo UKU [in Ukrainian].

Published
01.07.2019
How to Cite
Dmytrenko, V. (2019). Causes of Conflicts between Parish Priests of Pyriatyn Protopopia in the second half of the 18th century. EMINAK: Scientific Quarterly Journal, (2(26), 20-27. https://doi.org/10.33782/eminak2019.2(26).285
Section
History of Ukraine