Peculiar Features of the Historical Development of Pakistan Statehood

Keywords: statehood, Islam, Sunnis, Shiites, Pakistan, South Asia, atomic weapons


The paper analyzes the main features of the historical development of Pakistan statehood. The idea of creating a «pure» Islamic state caused primarily the separation of Pakistan from British India in 1947. Since then, the Islamic factor has become crucial for the evolution of Pakistan statehood. Pakistan is a federation of tribes with weak central institutions, although the state has qualified post-colonial elite. Some Pakistani Muslims consider Islam to be a perfect religion that does not require a Western model of democracy. Others believe that Islam is democratic in its essence. In response, radical Islamists call Western forms of education incompatible with Islamic values. Pakistan political system is characterized by personalist authoritarianism as an authoritarian regime of power. Armed forces under the authoritarian regimes are not only the instrument of the power of ruling bureaucratic groups but also directly influence political processes, the transformation of social structures, development of the main trends of domestic and foreign policy. It is proved that the formation of the Pakistan political nation is complicated with interethnic, confessional, socio-economic and regional contradictions. Political elites in Pakistan had determined the confrontation with India as the strategic objective of the state. It is shown that the creation of atomic weapons only emphasized the asymmetry of the potential of India and Pakistan. The possession of atomic weapons could not solve the «tribal» problems of Pakistan statehood.


Belokrenickii, V.Ya. (2008). Etnoregionnalnye i religiozno-sektanskie konflikty v Pakistane [Ethnoregional and religious-sectarian conflicts in Pakistan]. In Konflikty na Vostoke: etnicheskie i konfessionalnye (pp. 341-350). Moskva: Nauka [in Russian].

Belokrenickii, V.Ya. (2005). Personalistskiy avtoritarism v Pakistanie (k voprosu o politicheskoy culture i rezhyme vlasti v vostochom variante)[ Personalist authoritarianism in Pakistan (on the issue of political culture and regime of power in the eastern version)]. Vostok.6. 73-90. [in Russian].

Belokrenickii, V.Ya. & Moskalenko, V.N. (2003). Istoriay Pakistana. XX vek. [The history of Pakistan. Twentieth century.]. Moskva: Institut vostokovedenia RAN. [in Rassian].

Benazir, Bhutto (1991). Doch vostoka [Daughter of the East]. Moskva: Politizdat [in Russian].

Bzhezinskii, Zb. (2012). Strategichne bachennia. Ameryka i kryza svitovoi vlady [Strategic Vision. America and the crisis of world power]. Lviv: Litopys [in Ukrainian].

Entsiklopediia Pakistana (1998). [Encyclopaedia of Pakistan]. Moskva: Vostochnaia literatura [in Russian].

Filimonova, A.L. (2010). Etnoregionalizm versus musulmanskaia obshnost v Britanskoi Indii [Ethnoregionalism versus Muslim community in British India]. Vostok, 5, 86-92 [in Russian].

Hafeez, M. (2001). Pakistan: Founders aspirations and today’s realities. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Haqqani, Hasan (2005). Pakistan: Between Mosque and Military. Washington: Cartoon Books.

Ignatev, P.M. (2006). Indiia na shliahu do liderstva v Pivdennii Azii [India on the Way to Leadership in South Asia]. Chernivci: Ruta [in Ukrainian].

Mathur, Alok (1994). «The 2-nation Theory». A Study in the Context of Crises in Pakistan. Jaipur: Publishing Books.

Pleshov, O. (2003). Islam i politicheskaia kultura obshestva. Paradoksy konservativnoi tradicii [Islam and the political culture of society. Paradoxes of the conservative tradition]. Aziia i Afrika segodnia, 2, 20-32 [in Russian].

Pleshov, O. (2003). Islam, islamizm i nominalnaia demokratiia v Pakistane [Islam, Islamism and Nominal Democracy in Pakistan]. Moskva: Vostochnaia literatura [in Russian].

Tyssovskii, Yu.K. (2011) «Krestonoscy» protiv islama [«Crusaders» against Islam]. T. 1. Moskva: Nauka [in Russian].

Vasilev, L.E. (2011). Osobennosti borby s terrorismom v stranakh Tsentralnoi Azii v sovremeenyh usloviiah [Features of the fight against terrorism in Central Asia in modern conditions]. In Mirovye derzhavy v Centralnoi Azii. Moskva: IDV RAN [in Russian].

Vikram, Sud (2010). Radikalnyi islam v regione i ego vliianie na Yuzhnuiu Aziiu [Radical Islam in the region and its influence on South Asia].In Radikalnyi islam. Vzgliad iz Indii i Rossii (pp. 50-83). Moskva: MOF-ETC [in Russian].

Vilson, Dzhon (2010). Dolgaia voina radikalnogo islama v Pakistane [The long war of radical Islam in Pakistan]. In Radikalnyi islam. Vzgliad iz Indii i Rossii (pp. 401-403). Moskva: MOF-ETC [in Russian].

Vorobev, V.V. (2011). Pravlenie Muhammada Ziia-ul-Haka i ego vliianie na razvitie Pakistana [Reign of Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq and his influence on the development of Pakistan]. Vostok, 1, 85-97 [in Russian].

How to Cite
Horobets, I. (2019). Peculiar Features of the Historical Development of Pakistan Statehood. EMINAK: Scientific Quarterly Journal, (2(26), 122-132.
World History and International Relations