Muslim Ministers in French Governments (2012-2017)

Keywords: Islam, Muslim politicians, government, Francois Hollande, France

Abstract

At the beginning of the 21st century, the French Republic was home to the largest Muslim community in the West, numbering 5-6 million people. E. Macron’s initiatives aimed at defending the principle of secularism and combating ‘Islamist separatism’ provoked outrage in the Islamic world. The republic was blamed for systematic discrimination against Muslims and the lack of opportunities for self-realization of community members. Therefore, the analysis of the state of representation of Muslim politicians in the highest echelons of power is relevant.

The goal of the paper is to analyze the composition of French governments during the presidency of Francois Hollande and to trace the role played by Muslims in them, using a variety of sources (official state press, Senate and National Assembly reports, transcripts of speeches, interviews, and memoirs).

The concurrence of government was conceptual for F. Hollande. Therefore, three of the four Muslim politicians (Najat Vallaud-Belkacem, Myriam El Khomri, Kader Arif) were members of the pro-presidential Socialist Party. And formally non-party Yamina Benguigui gravitated to the Left. F. Hollande repeated, initiated by N. Sarkozy, the precedent of appointing Muslims as full-fledged ministers, not just delegated ministers or secretaries of state. If in the first case it was a matter of such a prestigious department as the Ministry of Justice, in the second it was about the ideologically important Ministry of National Education, Higher Education and Research. At the same time, the appointment of Kader Arif as Secretary of State for Veterans Affairs parallels with the appointment of Jacques Chirac to the same position in 2002-2007.

Three of the four politicians (K. Arif, N. Vallaud-Belkacem, and M. El Khomri) were not born in France. Two (N. Vallaud-Belkacem and M. El Khomri) retained dual citizenship. Therefore, in their rhetoric, they appealed to the cultural, religious and ethnic diversity of the Republic. And the issues of history, the politics of memory, secularism, the fight against all forms of discrimination were of top priority for them. Periodically trying to protect Islamic culture and the Muslim community from grievances, all three politicians violated one of the basic rules of fiqh, marrying a non-Muslim: Najat Vallaud-Belkacem and Myriam El Khomri married Christians, and Yamina Benguigui married the Jew of Algerian descent. And if to compare this with the fact that they all were activists of the women’s movement, it looks like they tried to receive the maximum dividends from the Republic. That would be impossible in a traditional Muslim society. At the same time, they appealed to the need to protect universal Islamic values. And they postulated themselves as ‘secular Muslims’, which is a priori impossible for classical Islam.

References

Aufray, S. (2014). Le site Mémoire des hommes et ses évolutions: entre mémoire et histoire [The site Mémoire des hommes and its evolutions: between memory and history]. La Gazette des archives, 236, 71-83; DOI: https://doi.org/10.3406/gazar.2014.5164 [in French].

Cardoso, A. (2014). La superwoman est-elle antiféministe? Analyse des discours de la presse féminine sur l’articulation entre vie professionnelle et vie familiale [The superwoman is she antiféministe? Discourse analysis of women's magazines on the relationship between work and family life]. Recherches féministes, 27 (1), 219-236. DOI: https://doi.org/10.7202/1025424ar [in French].

Collombet, C. (2016). Histoire des congés parentaux en France. Une lente sortie du modèle de rémunération de la mère au foyer [History of parental leave in France. A slow exit from the stay-at-home mom pay model]. Revue des politiques sociales et familiales, 122, 111-122. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3406/caf.2016.3168 [in French].

Fleuri, B. (2008). Mémoires d’immigrés. L’heritage maghrébin de Yamina Benguigui. De l’ethos biographique aux hors sujets de la réception [Memories of immigrants. Yamina Benguigui’s Maghrebian heritage. From the biographical ethos to subjects outside the reception]. Revues-analyses, 3, Vol. 3, 99-121 [in French].

Olland, F. (2019). Uroky vlady: memuary [Lessons of power: memoirs]. Kharkiv: «Folio» [in Ukrainian].

Sypko, B. (2016). Etno-sotsialni problemy frantsuzkykh peredmist na zlami XX-XXI st. [Ethno-social problems of French suburbs at the turn of the XX-XXI centuries]. In Wspołczesne wyzwania bezpieczeństwa Europejskiego (pp. 203-217). Kraków: Wydawnictwo Attyka [in Ukrainian].

Sypko, B. (2020). Musulmany v uriadakh Fransua Fiiona [Muslims in the Governments of François Fillon]. Eminak: Scientific Quarterly Journal, 2 (30), 209-219. DOI: https://doi.org/10.33782/eminak2020.2(30).421 [in Ukrainian].

Sypko, B. (2017). Musulmanska spilnota u zhytti Frantsuzkoi Respubliky (1995-2007) [Muslim Community in the Life of French Republic (1995-2007)]. Lviv: The Ivan Franko National University of Lviv [in Ukrainian].

Sypko, B. (2013). Ot «zabytykh istoriei» do subieektov obshchestvennykh otnoshenii: problema kharki v gody prezidentskoi kadentsii Zhaka Shiraka [From «forgotten by history» to subjects of social relations: the problem of the Harkis during the presidency of Jacques Chirac]. Społeczeństwo i Polityka. Pismo edukacyjne, 3 (36), 229-239 [in Russian].

Sypko, B. (2017). Politychne zhyttia frantsuzkykh musulman: vid uchasti u vyborakh do uriadovykh posad (1995-2007) [Political life of French Muslims: from participation in elections to government posts (1995-2007)]. Visnyk of the Lviv University. Series History. Special Issue, 745-760. DOI: https://doi.org/10.30970/his.2017.0 [in Ukrainian].

Windisch, J. (2014). Omniprésence de l’image – omniprésence du président: Les caricatures sur Nicolas Sarkozy (2007-2012) [Omnipresence of the image ‒ omnipresence of President: The cartoons on Nicolas Sarkozy (2007-2012)]. Wien: Universität Wien [in French].

Published
01.07.2021
How to Cite
SypkoB. (2021). Muslim Ministers in French Governments (2012-2017). Eminak: Scientific Quarterly Journal, (2(34), 238-255. https://doi.org/10.33782/eminak2021.2(34).531
Section
World History and International Relations