‘Battles for Hrushevskyi’: Era of Ukrainian Revolution in Diaspora Intellectuals Discussions of Post-War Twenty Years

Keywords: M. Hrushevskyi, Ukrainian revolution, foreign historiography, reception, conservative ideology

Abstract

The aim of this study is to clear up the peculiarities of the discussion about M. Hrushevskyi’s social and political activity in the historiography of Ukrainian diaspora. At the same time, the emphasis is placed on the least known period of foreign Hrushevskyi studies, when the prominent intellectual’s body of work was studied by his younger contemporaries and colleagues who were lucky enough to be on the other side of the ‘Iron Curtain’. Attention is also paid to the brightest page of Hrushevskyi’s biography as a politician – when he was a Head of the Central Rada, which still causes a lot of discussions today.

The scientific novelty of the paper is in the comprehensive study of the little-known issue of receptive Hrushevskyi studies – the clarification of the peculiarities of interpreting M. Hrushevskyi’s social and political activity during the years of revolution by Ukrainian intellectuals abroad in the second half of the 1940s – the first half of the 1960s.

Conclusions. The most debatable issues of Hrushevskyi studies discourse are clarified: the rapid leaning by the Head of the Central Rada more towards the left views, his attitude to the army, the reasons of the scientist’s federalistic views, etc. The ideological context of the historiographical discussions is reproduced. It consisted in the competition of diaspora intellectuals, who represented the republican and hetman party environments, for the inculcation of their own interpretation of the events of Ukrainian revolution in the minds of exiled Ukrainians. Those discussions were influenced by the emerging of new factual material and original interpretive models, brought by the memoirs of M. Hrushevskyi’s contemporaries. Also, the general progress of Ukrainian humanitaristics in the free world stimulated a rethinking of classical Hrushevskyi studies issues. Thanks to this, for example, a completely original view of the federalistic model of a prominent figure is formed. In general, the social and political Hrushevskyi studies of the mentioned twenty-year period make it possible gradually to reach new problem-thematic horizons.

References

Andrusiak, M. (1935). Dumky Hrushevskoho pro potrebu ukrainskoi armii [Hrushevsky’s thoughts on the need for the Ukrainian army]. Litopys Chervonoi Kalyny, 3, 7-8 [in Ukrainian].

Andrusiak, M. (1954). Mykhailo Hrushevskyi (U 20-littia smerty batka sohochasnoi ukrainskoi istoriohrafii) [Mykhailo Hrushevsky (On the 20th Anniversary of the death of the father of modern Ukrainian historiography)]. Svoboda, 227, 2 [in Ukrainian].

Hyrych, I. (2009). Hrushevskoznavstvo 1994-2009 rokiv na storinkakh “Ukrainskoho istoryka” [Hrushevskoznavstvo 1994-2009 on the pages of “Ukrainian historian”]. Ukrainskyi istoryk, 1-4 (181-184), 62-79 [in Ukrainian].

Hyrych, I. (2019). Lysty Mykoly Haliia do Volodymyra Doroshenka z arkhivu UVAN (SShA). Do istorii vykhodu pershoi posmertnoi knyhy publitsystyky M. Hrushevskoho (Niu-York, 1960 r.) [Mykola Galiy’s letters to Volodymyr Doroshenko from the UVAN archive (USA). To the history of the publication of the first posthumous book of journalism by M. Hrushevsky (New York, 1960)]. Mykhailo Hrushevskyi. Studii ta Dzherela, 2, 395-475 [in Ukrainian].

Hyrych, I. (2006). M. Hrushevskyi i I. Franko: do istorii vzaiemyn [M. Hrushevsky and I. Franko: to the history of relations]. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal, 5, 35-67 [in Ukrainian].

Doroshenko, V. (1957). M. Hrushevskyi – hromadskyi diiach, polityk i publitsyst [M. Hrushevsky – public figure, politician and publicist]. Ovyd, 10, 23-26 [in Ukrainian].

Doroshenko, V. (1957). Pershyi prezydent vidnovlenoi ukrainskoi derzhavy (Akad. Mykhailo Hrushevskyi, yoho zhyttia y diialnist) [The first president of the restored Ukrainian state (Acad. Mykhailo Hrushevsky, his life and work)]. Ovyd, 2-3, 27-32 [in Ukrainian].

Lavrinenko, Yu. (1959). Mykhailo Hrushevskyi [Mykhailo Hrushevskyi]. Rozstriliane Vidrodzhennia. Antolohiia 1917-1933, Paryzh-Miunkhen: Instytut Literacki, 907-919 [in Ukrainian].

Mazepa, I. (1950). Ukraina v ohni y buri revoliutsii 1917-1921 [Ukraine in the fire and storm of the revolution of 1917-1921]. N. d.: “Prometei” [in Ukrainian].

Marenin, M. (1960). Dvi zustrichi z prof. M. Hrushevskym [Two meetings with prof. M. Hrushevsky]. Lysty do pryiateliv, 4 (86), 7-9 [in Ukrainian].

Ohloblyn, O. (2006-2007). Vchennia M. Hrushevskoho pro movu – movnu spilnotu – narod – rasu [M. Hrushevsky’s doctrine of language – language community – people – race]. Ukrainskyi istoryk, 4 (172) /1-2 (173-174), 206-235 [in Ukrainian].

Ohloblyn, O. (1964). Mykhailo Hrushevskyi i ukrainske natsionalne vidrodzhennia [Mykhailo Hrushevsky and the Ukrainian national revival]. Ukrainskyi istoryk, 2-3, 1-6 [in Ukrainian].

Onatskyi, Ye. (1965). M. Hrushevskyi: Chesnist z narodom [M. Hrushevsky: Honesty with the people]. Portrety v profil (Chykaho), pp. 285-297 [in Ukrainian].

Pankova, S. (2016). Volume 3 of the History of Ukraine-Rus’ in Mykhailo Hrushevsky’s Creative Laboratory. Mykhailo Hrushevsky. History of Ukraine-Rus’. Edmonton; Toronto: Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies Press, volume 3, ХХІІІ-ХLVII [in English].

Pankova, S. (2017). Volume 4 of the History of Ukraine-Rus’: Between Two «Ukrainian Wings in Mighty National Flight». Mykhailo Hrushevsky. History of Ukraine-Rus’. Edmonton; Toronto, volume 4, ХХІ-ХLVІІ [in English].

Pelenskyi, Ya. (2019). Ukrainska natsionalna ideia u svitli tvoriv Mykhaila Hrushevskoho ta Viacheslava Lypynskoho [Ukrainian national idea in the light of works by Mykhailo Hrushevsky and Vyacheslav Lypynsky]. Kyiv: Nash format [in Ukrainian].

Romanenchuk, B. (1957). Problema «halychanstva» y pochuttia menshevartosty [The problem of “Galicianness” and feelings of inferiority]. Kyiv, 5 (veresen-zhovten), 201-210 [in Ukrainian].

Stachiw, M.A. (1957). Scientist and Social Leader as President of a State. The Ukrainian Quarterly, 4, 329-336 [in English].

Stakhiv, M. (1958). Uchenyi i suspilnyi filosof yak prezydent derzhavy. Profesor Mykhailo Hrushevskyi yak providnyk ukrainskoi natsionalnoi revoliutsii i pershyi prezydent Ukrainskoi narodnoi respubliky [Scientist and social philosopher as president. Professor Mykhailo Hrushevsky as the leader of the Ukrainian national revolution and the first president of the Ukrainian People’s Republic]. Vilna Ukraina, 17, 2-9 [in Ukrainian].

Telvak, V. (2008). Tvorcha spadshchyna Mykhaila Hrushevskoho v otsinkakh suchasnykiv (kinets XIX – 30-ti roky XX stolittia) [Mykhailo Hrushevsky’s creative heritage in the estimations of contemporaries (end of the XIX – 30s of the XX century)]. Kyiv-Drohobych: «Vymir» [in Ukrainian].

Telvak, V. (2021). Suchasne hrushevskoznavstvo: zdobutky, vtraty, perspektyvy [Modern Hrushevsky studies: achievements, defeats, prospects]. Ukrainskyi istorychnyi zhurnal, 5, 4-16. DOI: https://doi.org/10.15407/uhj2021.05.004 [in Ukrainian].

Telvak, V. & Ilnytskyi, V. (2018). Mykhailo Hrushevsky and Nicolae Iorga: scholars’ struggle over the national history. Codrul Cosminului, XXIV, 1, 53-64 [in English].

Telvak, V., Pedych, V. & Telvak, V. (2021). Historical school of Mykhailo Hrushevsky in Lviv: formation, structure, personal contribution. Studia Historiae Scientiarum, 20, 239-261. DOI: 10.4467/2543702XSHS.21.009.14040 [in English].

Telvak, V. & Salata, O. (2021). Reception of Hrushevsky studies: epistolary aspect. Skhidnoievropeiskyi istorychnyi visnyk, 20, 32-39. DOI: 10.24919/2519-058X.20.240046 [in English].

Telvak, V. & Telvak, V. (2019). Mykhailo Hrushevsky in Czech historiography (the first third of the 20th century). Codrul Cosminului, XXV, 2, 265-286. DOI: 10.4316/CC.2019.02.002 [in English].

Telvak, V. & Telvak, V. (2018). Ukrainian historiography in the mirror of polish journalism (Mykhailo Hrushevsky contra Francishek Ravita-Gavronsky). Skhidnoievropeiskyi istorychnyi visnyk, 7, 46-53. DOI: 10.24919/2519-058x.7.130671 [in English].

Telvak, V. & Yanyshyn, B. (2021). “Geschichte des Ukrainischen (Ruthenischen) volkes” of Mykhailo Hrushevsky in the discussions of the beginning of the XXth century. Studia Historica Nitriensia, 25, 1, 71-90. DOI: 10.17846/SHN.2021.25.1.71-90 [in English].

Telvak, V., Yanyshyn, B. & Telvak, V. (2021). Between history and politics: the image of Mykhailo Hrushevsky in German Slavic studies of the first third of the 20th century. Przegląd nauk historycznych, XX, 2, 103-125. DOI: 10.18778/1644-857X.20.02.05 [in English].

Vilna Ukraina (1958). Hrushevskyi i… Romanenchuk [Hrushevsky and… Romanenchuk]. Vilna Ukraina, 17, 71-72 [in Ukrainian].

Published
07.07.2022
How to Cite
TelvakV., & SabinskyiM. (2022). ‘Battles for Hrushevskyi’: Era of Ukrainian Revolution in Diaspora Intellectuals Discussions of Post-War Twenty Years. Eminak: Scientific Quarterly Journal, (1(37), 100-109. https://doi.org/10.33782/eminak2022.1(37).574
Section
Modern History