Transformation of the Traditional Religiosity of the Ukrainian Peasantry (1920s – 1930s): Conceptualization of Research Problem
Abstract
The purpose of the research paper is to highlight the set of circumstances and factors that caused the transformation of the peasantry traditional religiosity and to emphasize the interdependence of the processes in the event-contextual and mental-conscious spheres/dimensions.
Scientific novelty: Despite the rather thorough scientific analysis of the issue, the dominance of the positivist approach is observed in historiography; therefore, the conceptualization of the problem makes it possible to understand the non-fragmentary factual multiplicity of certain plots, which evinced in one way or another the transformations of religiosity in the social and cultural space of the 1920s – 1930s, but it allows to clarify and generalize the reasons, nature, dynamics, and essential characteristics of the processes related to the transformation of religiosity under the new social and cultural conditions of the communist-atheist power.
Conclusions. There is a certain dependency between the architectonics of human existence and the worldview benchmarks of a certain era. Therefore, not only anti-religious and anti-church propaganda (as a means of ideological influence), but also the socio-economic and political development of society (industrialization, collectivization, cultural revolution, renewal of everyday life, etc.) destroyed the former stable world of customs and rituals. Therefore, it is obviously worth talking not about the transformation of religiosity, but about complex transformations.
The nature of the religiosity transformational processes depended on many factors. In the context of the eroding of old church doctrines, the revision of fixed moral and ethical norms, the onset of atheism, in the eyes of Christians, the stable world was degrading, losing sanctified traditions and moral standards. Religious integrity and the durability of religious culture were lost. In search of compensation for the emerging worldview uncertainty, anxiety, dissatisfaction, etc., the individual looked for new benchmarks, values, ideals, and ways of organizing life in society through the transformation of stable forms and ways of life. In the confrontation of two worldview cultural models, society, having undergone complex transformations, slowly adapted to the conditions established by the communist regime and its worldview instructions.
References
Arutiunyan, Y. (1972). Izmenenie socialnoi struktury sovetskoi natsii [Change in the social structure of the Soviet nation]. Istoria SSSR, 4, 4-10 [in Russian].
Buchma, O.V. (2019). Relihiinist [Religiosity]. Velyka ukrainska entsyklopediia. Retrieved from https://vue.gov.ua/Релігійність [in Ukrainian].
Diakiv, V. (2008). «Folklor chudes» u pidradianskiy Ukraini 1920-h rokiv [«Folklore of Miracles» in the Soviet Ukraine of the 1920s]. Lviv [in Ukrainian].
Diakiv, V. (2010). Proiavy religiinosti ukraintsiv v umovakh bilshovytskoi okupatsii pochatku 1920-kh rokiv [Manifestations of religiosity of Ukrainians under the Bolshevik occupation of the early 1920s]. Visnyk Lvivskoho universytetu. Seria: Filologia, 43, 169-180 [in Ukrainian].
Diakiv, V. (2012). Spetsyfika narodnoi relihiinosti ukraintsiv v umovakh bilshovytskoi okupatsii 1930-kh rr. [The specifics of popular religiosity of Ukrainians in the conditions of Bolshevik occupation in the 1930s]. Narodoznavchi zoshyty, 6 (108), 976-994 [in Ukrainian].
Drovoziuk, S.I. (2002). Masovyi relihiinyi rukh v Ukraini u 20-kh rr. XX st.: istoriohrafiia problemy [Mass religious movement in Ukraine in the 20s of the 20th century: historiography of the problem]. Naukovi zapysky Vinnytskoho derzhavnoho pedahohichnoho universytetu imeni Mykhaila Kotsiubynskoho. Seriia: Istoriia, 4, 247-253 [in Ukrainian].
Halamai, O. (2002). Relihiini chudesa na Vinnychchyni [Religious miracles in Vinnytsia region]. Vinnychchyna: istoria ta suchasnist, 50-54 [in Ukrainian].
Heorhizov, H. (2015). Formuvannia novoi svidomosti ukrainskoho selianstva (1920-1929 rr.) [The formation of a new consciousness of the Ukrainian peasantry (1920-1929)]. Cherkasy [in Ukrainian].
Herchanivska, P. (2011). Ukrainska narodna kultura: khrystyianskyi vymir [Ukrainian folk culture: the Christian dimension]. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].
Hruzova, T.S. (2020). Relihiine zhyttia v USRR v umovakh upokorennia holodom (1932-1933 rr.) [The Religious Life in the Ukrainian SSR in Terror-Famine Conditions (1932-1933)]. Zaporizhzhia Historical Review, 2 (54). DOI: 10.26661/zhv-2020-2-54-16 [in Ukrainian].
Ihnatusha, O. (2004). Instytutsiynyi rozkol pravoslavnoi tserkvy v Ukraini: heneza i kharakter (ХІХ – 30-і rr. ХХ st.) [The institutional split of the Orthodox Church in Ukraine: genesis and nature (XIX – 30s of the XX century)]. Zaporizzia [in Ukrainian].
Ihnatusha, O. (2009). Zakryttia tserkov i religiyna svidomist: 20-30-ti rr. ХХ st. [Closing of churches and religious consciousness: 20-30s of the 20th century]. Naukovi zapysky Natsionalnoho universytetu “Ostrozka academia”. Seria: Istorychne relihieznavstvo, 1, 75-86 [in Ukrainian].
Kompaniiets, I.I. (Ed.) (1967). Istoriia selianstva Ukrainskoi RSR. T. II: Vid Velykoho Zhovtnia do nashykh dniv [History of the peasantry of the Ukrainian SSR. Volume II. From Great October to the present day]. Kyiv: Naukova dumka [in Ukrainian].
Kulchytskyi, S.V. (Ed.) (2010). Narysy povsiakdennoho zhyttia radianskoi Ukrainy v dobu nepu (1921-1928 rr.) [Essays on everyday life in Soviet Ukraine during the NEP period (1921-1928)]: Kyiv: Instytut istorii Ukrainy NAN Ukrainy [in Ukrainian].
Kulchytskyi, S.V. (Ed.) (2012). Ukrainske radianske suspilstvo 30-kh rr. XX st.: narysy povsiakdennoho zhyttia [Ukrainian Soviet society in the 1930s of the 20th century: essays on everyday life]. Kyiv: Instytut istorii Ukrainy NAN Ukrainy [in Ukrainian].
Kambur, A. (2012). Sotsialna adaptatsiia osobystosti [Social adaptation of personality]. Chernivtsi [in Ukrainian].
Kyrydon, A. (1997). Relihiia yak riznovyd ideolohii v protsesi derzhavotvorennia [Religion as a kind of ideology in the process of state formation]. In Ideia natsionalnoi tserkvy v Ukraini. Ternopil, 49-51 [in Ukrainian].
Kyrydon, A. (1999). Ideologichnyy monism yak chynnyk derzavno-cerkovnyh vzayemyn v Ukraini [Ideological monism as a factor in state-church relations in Ukraine]. Istoria religiy v Ukraini. Knyga 1. Lviv, 153-155 [in Ukrainian].
Kyrydon, A. (2004). Evoliutsiia polityky partiino-derzhavnoho kerivnytstva radianskoi Ukrainy shchodo relihii i tserkvy (1917-1930-ti roky) [The evolution of the policy of the party-state leadership of Soviet Ukraine regarding religion and the church (1917-1930s]. Istorychnyi zhurnal, 6-7, 20-31 [in Ukrainian].
Kyrydon, A.M. (2005). Chas vyprobuvan. Derzhava. Tserkva. Suspilstvo v radianskii Ukraini (1917-1930-ti) [Testing time. State. Church. Society in Soviet Ukraine (1917-1930s)]. Ternopil: Pidruchnyky i posibnyky [in Ukrainian].
Kyrydon, A. (2009). Kohnityvnyi dysonans v umovakh utverdzhennia totalitaryzmu [Cognitive dissonance in the conditions of establishment of totalitarianism]. Naukovi zapysky Natsionalnoho universytetu “Ostrozka academia”. Seria: Istorychne relihieznavstvo, 1, 87-101 [in Ukrainian].
Kyrydon, A. (2012). Relihiino-tserkovne zhyttia v Ukraini (1932-1933 rr.) [Religious and church life in Ukraine (1932-1933)]. Slovianskyi visnyk. Seriia «Istorychni ta politychni nauky», 13, 51-57 [in Ukrainian].
Kyrydon, A. (2013). Ruinuvannia kultovykh sporud (1920-1930-ti rr.): porushennia tradytsiynoi rytmolohii prostoru [Destruction of religious buildings (1920-1930s): violation of the traditional rhythmology of space]. Problemy istorii Ukrainy: fakty, sudzhennia, poshuky, 22, 91-102 [in Ukrainian].
Kyrydon, A. (2017). Desakralizatsiia prostoru (1920-1930-i rr.): smyslovi ta symvolichni zasady [Desacralization of space (1920-1930s): semantic and symbolic foundations]. Umanska starovyna, 1, 133-145 [in Ukrainian].
Kyrydon, A. (2017). Indoktrynatsiya radianskosti: obriadovo-sviatkovyi kanon yak marker formuvannia ateizovanoho suspilstva (1920-1930-i rr.) [Indoctrination of Sovietness: ritual and festive canon as a marker of the formation of an atheistic society (1920-1930s)]. Umanska starovyna, 3, 5-20 [in Ukrainian].
Markova, S.V. (2015). Suspilni ta politychni transformatsii v ukrainskomu seli v konteksti formuvannia totalitarnoi systemy (1917-1933 rr.) [Social and political transformations in the Ukrainian countryside in the context of the formation of the totalitarian system (1917-1933)]. Kamianets-Podilskyi [in Ukrainian].
Miahka, H. (2012). Kulturno-osvitnii riven ta relihiine zhyttia selianstva radianskoi ukrainy (20-i roky ХХ st.) [Cultural and educational level and religious life of the peasantry of Soviet Ukraine (20s of the 20th century)]. Istorychni zapysky, 35, 172-178 [in Ukrainian].
Minaiev, S. (1928). Naslidky vseliudnoho perepysu 1926 r. na Ukraini. Naselennia Ukrainy. Miskyi zhytlovyi fond [Consequences of the universal census of 1926 in Ukraine. Population of Ukraine. City housing fund]. Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].
Oliinyk, M. (2013). Proiavy chudes ta onovlennia ikon na Podilli v 1923 r. ta borotba vlady z tsym yavyschem [Manifestations of miracles and renewal of icons in Podillya in 1923 and the government’s struggle with this phenomenon]. Osvita, nauka i kultura na Podilli, 20, 509-519 [in Ukrainian].
Oryshchenko, R. (2018). Relihiinist yak chynnyk modernoi transformatsii ukrainskoho selianstva pershoi tretyny ХХ st. [Religiosity as a factor in the modern transformation of the Ukrainian peasantry in the first third of the 20th century]. Visnyk Kyivskoho natsionalnoho universytetu imeni Tarasa Shevchenka. Seriia: Istoriia, 139, 57-61 [in Ukrainian].
Oryshchenko, R. (2018). «Zarazhennia komunizmom» yak chynnyk likvidatsii tradytsiinoi relihiinosti ukrainskoho selianstva (1917 – pochatok 1930-kh rr.) [“Infection with communism” as a factor in the elimination of the traditional religiosity of the Ukrainian peasantry (1917 – early 1930s]. Visnyk Cherkaskoho universytetu. Seriia: Istorychni nauky, 3-4, 129-133 [in Ukrainian].
Oryshchenko, R. & Prysiazhniuk, Yu. (2018). Bohovidstupnytstvo yak radykalna zmina tradytsiinoi relihiinosti ukrainskoho selianstva (1920-i – pochatok 1930-kh rr.) [Apostasy as a radical change in the traditional religiosity of the Ukrainian peasantry (1920s – early 1930s)]. Ukrainskyi selianyn, 19, 118-122 [in Ukrainian].
Oryshchenko, R. (2019). Relihiinist ukrainskoho selianstva Naddniprianshchyny (1861-1933 rr.): istorychnyi vymir [Religiosity of the Ukrainian peasantry of the Dnieper region (1861-1933): historical dimension] (Extended abstract of Candidate’s thesis). Cherkasy [in Ukrainian].
Panasiuk, M. (2019). Religiina tvorchist podolian v 1920-kh rr. [Religious creativity of the Podolians in the 1920s]. Naukovi zapysky Ternopilskoho natsionalnoho pedahohichnoho universytetu imeni Volodymyra Hnatiuka. Seria: Istoria, 2, 123-127 [in Ukrainian].
Pashchenko, V. & Kyrydon, A. (2004). Bilshovytska derzhava i pravoslavna tserkva v Ukraini. 1917-1930-i roky [The Bolshevik State and the Orthodox Church in Ukraine. 1917-1930s]. Poltava: ASMI [in Ukrainian].
Prysiazniuk, Yu. (2007). Ukrainske selianstvo Naddniprianskoi Ukrainy: sotsiomentalna istoria druhoi polovyny ХІХ – pochatku ХХ st. [The Ukrainian peasantry of Dnieper Ukraine: socio-mental history of the second half of the 19th and early 20th centuries]. Cherkasy [in Ukrainian].
Prysiazniuk, Yu. (2018). Ukrainske selianstvo v konteksti suchasnykh doslidnytskykh zavdan [Ukrainian peasantry in the context of modern research tasks]. Ukrainskyi selianyn, 20, 74-79 [in Ukrainian].
Prysiazhniuk, Yu.P. (2021). Selo v umovakh polityky ateizatsii suspilstva 1920-kh rokiv: vtrata viry [The village in the conditions of the politics of atheisation of society of the 1920s: loss of faith]. Ukrainskyi selianyn, 26, 26-31. DOI: 10.31651/2413-8142-2021-26-Prysiazhniuk [in Ukrainian].
Silantiev, V. (1998). Bolsheviki i Pravoslavnaya tserkov na Ukraine v 20-e gody [Bolsheviks and the Orthodox Churchchurch in Ukraine in the 1920s]. Kharkov [in Russian].
Stadnyk, O. & Kuzminets, N. (2020). Relihiine zhyttia podilskoho sela u vymirakh radianskoi povsiakdennosti 20-kh rr. ХХ st. [Religious life of a Podil village in the dimensions of Soviet everyday life in the 1920s]. Naukovi zapysky Vinnytskoho derzhavnoho pedahohichnoho universytetu imeni Mykhaila Kotsiubynskoho. Seria: Istoria, 31, 79-87 [in Ukrainian].
Stasiuk, O. (2007). Transformatsiia simeinoi obriadovosti ukraintsiv naprykintsi 20-kh – pochatku 30-kh rr. XX st. [Transformation of Ukrainian family rituals in the late 1920s – early 1930s]. Etnichna istoriia narodiv Yevropy, 22, 102-109 [in Ukrainian].
Stasiuk, O. (2005). Deformatsiia ukrainskoi tradytsiinoi kultury v 1929-1934 rokakh [Deformation of Ukrainian traditional culture in 1929-1934]. Etnichna istoriia narodiv Yevropy, 20, 95-99 [in Ukrainian].
Stasiuk, O. (2006). Transformatsiia tradytsiinoi kultury ukraintsiv v kintsi 1920-kh – na pochatku 1930-kh rr. [The transformation of the traditional culture of Ukrainians in the late 1920s – early 1930s]. Naukovi zapysky. Seriia: Istoriia, 10, 134-138 [in Ukrainian].
Sylantiev, V. & Oliinyk, M. (2008). Modernizatsiya polityko-pravovykh i orhanizatsiinykh zasad derzhavno-tserkovnykh vidnosyn v Ukraini za chasiv revoliutsiinykh podiy i sotsialistychnykh peretvoren 1917-1930 rr. [Modernization of the political, legal and organizational foundations of State-Church relations in Ukraine during the revolutionary events and socialist transformations of 1917-1930]. Visnyk Natsionalnoho tehnichnoho universytetu Kharkivskyi politekhnichnyi instytut, 37, 91-99 [in Ukrainian].
Trygub, O. (2006). Relihiinist naselennia Pivdnia Ukrainy za chasiv NEPu (1921-1929 rr.): pravoslavnyi aspekt [Religiosity of the population of Southern Ukraine during the NEP (1921-1929): Orthodox aspect]. Naukovi pratsi. Seria: Istorychni nauky, 48 (35), 31-36 [in Ukrainian].
Trygub, O.(2006). Selianstvo ta rozkol Rosiiskoi pravoslavnoi tserkvy 1920-kh rr. [The peasantry and the schism of the Russian Orthodox Church in the 1920s]. Ukrainskyi selianyn, 10, 148-152 [in Ukrainian].
Yaroslavskiy, Ye. (1937). Antireligioznaya propaganda v sovremennykh usloviyakh [Anti-religious propaganda in modern conditions]. Bolshevik, 4, 33 [in Russian].
Yaroslavskiy, Ye. (1937). Zadachi antireligioznoi propagandy. Ob antireligioznoi propagande. Sbornik [Tasks of anti-religious propaganda. About anti-religious propaganda. Collection]. Moskva [in Russian].
Yevsieiev, O.I. (Ed.) (1959). Kulturne budivnytstvo v Ukrainskii RSR: vazhlyvi rishennia Komunistychnoi partii i Radianskoho uriadu: 1917-1959 rr.: zbirnyk dokumentiv u 2 t. [Cultural construction in the Ukrainian SSR: important decisions of the Communist Party and the Soviet government: 1917-1959: a collection of documents in 2 volumes]. Vol. 1 (1917-1941). Kyiv: Derzhpolitvydav URSR, 1959 [in Ukrainian].
Zavalniuk, K. & Stetsiuk, T. (2007). Relihiyni chudesa na Podilli (20-ti roky XX stolittia) [Religious “miracles” in Podilla (1920s)]. Istoria relihii v Ukraini. Naukovyi shchorichnyk. Lviv, 409-419 [in Ukrainian].
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
