Masonic Movement in Central and Southern Ukraine in the 19th century: Loss of Hopes for Emancipation

Keywords: Masons, Masonic lodge, Alexander’s reforms, social progress, enlightenment, church, Ukrainian nation

Abstract

The epoch of world revolutions, the epoch of the formation of world ideas (the first half of the 19th century) gave rise to global projects of nationalism and the nation state, socialism and anarchism, emancipation, and public enlightenment, in the formation of which the Masonic ‘rulers of thoughts’ played an active role. The research paper uncovers the importance of the Masonic movement in the history of Ukraine and shows the contribution of the Masons to the formation of Ukrainian culture and the national idea, enlightenment, and self-organization of society.

The purpose of the study is to find answers to the questions: why elite groups of Ukrainian gubernias gathered at the secret lodges in the 19th century, what global and intermediate tasks they set, and which of them they managed to achieve. And most importantly, how the Masonic ‘building of the Temple’ influenced the processes of formation of the Ukrainian nation. To address this purpose, the authors use a synthetic approach combining the research capabilities of social philosophy, history, and political science.

The scientific novelty of the paper. A comprehensive study of the Masonic movement in the territory of Ukrainian gubernias of the Russian Empire has been conducted, extracting the Masonic movement from the historical context imposed by Russian-Soviet historiography. The authors mention Ukrainian Masons in Ukrainian history as ‘builders’ and ‘awakeners’ of a new society, where the democratic and national features of Ukraine were taken into account.

Conclusions. In the first quarter of the 19th century in Central and Southern Ukraine, the Masons managed to form four centers (Kharkiv, Poltava, Kyiv, and Odesa) in which they not only organized the liberal-minded local elite as an independent ‘horizontal structure’, but also began ‘Masonic creation’ – upbringing a new person, a supporter of social progress. A special contribution of Masonic authors to the creation of Ukrainian literature and theater, the first historical studies of Ukrainian history, and Ukrainian autonomist projects took place. Of great interest are the activities of the Masons in Ukraine after their formal ‘prohibition’ in 1822, and the attempts of Masonic leaders to influence events in Ukrainian gubernias, being ‘in the shadows’, in the rigid system of barracks imperialism of the ‘Nicholas era’.

References

Bagalei, D.I. (1898). Experience in the history of Kharkov University (based on unpublished materials). Vol. 1 (1802-1805). Kharkov: Parovaya tipografiys i litografiya Zilberberg [in Russian].

Baitsura, T. (1977). Ivan Semenovich Orlay. Life and activity. Bratislava: Slovatskoe pedagogicheskoe izdatelstvo; Pryashev: Otdelenie ukr. lit. [in Russian].

Bohdanova, T.E. (2004). Masonic organizations of Ukraine 1900-1917 in the works of the Polish researcher L. Gass. Naukovi pratsi: Naukovo-metodychnyi zhurnal, 32 (19): Istorychni nauky, 143-148 [in Ukrainian].

Doroshenko, D. (1929). Prince M. Repnin and D. Bantysh-Kamenskyi (A page from Ukrainian public life of the first quarter of the 19th century). Pratsi Ukrainskoho Vysokoho Pedagogichnoho Instytutu im. Mykhayla Drahomanova u Prazi. Vol. 1, 90-108 [in Ukrainian].

Dymchuk, A.V. (2020). The Philosophical Foundations of the Social Doctrine of Freemasonry (Candidate’s thesis). Odesa [in Ukrainian].

Dudrovich, A. (1818). About animal magnetism. Ukrainskiy vestnik (Kharkov), 2 (1), 125-138; 3, 253-268; 4, 62-79 [in Russian].

Efremov, S. (1918). Freemasonry in Ukraine. Nashe mynule (Kyiv), 3, 4-16 [in Ukrainian].

Florovskiy, A.V. (1913). From Odessa antiquity. Composition of the Masonic lodge ‘Pont Euxine’ in Odessa. Izvestiya Odesskogo bibliograficheskogo obshchestva, 9 (1), 8-14 [in Russian].

Hundorova, T. (2006). Franko and Kameniar. Slovo i Chas, 8, 15 [in Ukrainian].

Khodorovskyi, M. (2004). Freemasonry and Ukraine: according to the materials of the activities of free masons of the 18th century. Historical and archival essays. Lviv [in Ukrainian].

Kondakov, Yu.E. (2005). ‘Solid’ Mason D.P. Runich. In Kondakov, Yu.E. Liberal and conservative trends in religious movements in Russia in the first quarter of the 19th century. Sankt-Peterburg: Izdatelstvo RGPU im. A.I. Gertsena [in Russian].

Konopka, N. (2004). Little Russian Governor-General M.G. Repnin-Volkonsky and the development of the Masonic and Decembrist movements. Istoriohrafichni ta dzhereloznavchi problemy istorii Ukrainy, 44-54 [in Ukrainian].

Konopka, N. & Shkerin, V. (2011). Three versions of the history of the Masonic lodge ‘Love for the Truth to the East of Poltava’. Naukovi zapysky Natsionalnoho universytetu «Ostrozka akademiya»: Istorychni nauky, 17, 318-338 [in Ukrainian].

Kryzhanovska, O.O. (1998). Secret organizations in the social and political life of Ukraine (Masonic movement in the 18th – early 20th century). Kyiv: Aquilon-Press [in Ukrainian].

Kryzhanovska, O.O. (2010). Secret organizations: Masonic movement in Ukraine. Kyiv: Nash Chas [in Ukrainian].

Mashinsky, S.I. (1959). Gogol and the ‘case of freethinking’. Moskva: Sovetskiy pisatel [in Russian].

Melgunov, S.P. & Sidorov, N.P. (Eds.). (1915). Freemasonry in its past and present. Petrograd: Zadruga [in Russian].

Mordovtsev, D.L. (1878). About the Masonic lodge of the ‘United Slavs’. Russkaya starina, January, 187-189 [in Russian].

Mozgovaya, N.G. (2018). Orthodox ‘mysticism’ in domestic spiritual-academic philosophy of the 19th century. Aktualni problemy filosofiyi ta sotsiologiyi, 1, 33-35 [in Russian].

Ohloblin, O. (1959). People of Old Ukraine. Miunkhen: Dniprova khvylia [in Ukrainian].

Ohloblin, O.P. (1998). To the question about the author of ‘History of Rusov’. Kyiv: Instytut istorii NAN Ukrainy [in Ukrainian].

Oksman, Yu.G. (1923). Odessa freethinkers of Pushkin’s era. Byloye, 21, 49-56 [in Russian].

Orlay, I.S. (1804). The story of the Carpatho-Russians or the resettlement of Russians to the Carpathian Mountains and the adventures that happened to them. Severnyi vestnik, 1 (2), 158-172; 3, 261-276; 3 (8), 267-293 [in Russian].

Pavlovsky, I.F. (1918). From the past of Poltava region. To the history of the Decembrists. Poltava: Tipo-litografiya Tovarishchestva Pechatnogo Doma [in Russian].

Pavlovsky, I.F. (1909). Masonic lodge in Poltava. Trudy Poltavskoi uchenoi arkhivnoi komissii, 6 (1). Poltava: Elektr. tip. G.I. Markevicha [in Russian].

Popov, N.A. (1879). Ignatius Aurelius Fesler. Vestnik Yevropy, 4, 586-643 [in Russian].

Pypin, A. (2000). Religious movements under Alexander I. Sankt-Peterburg: Akademicheskiy proekt [in Russian].

Pypin, A.N. (1918). Research and articles on the era of Alexander I. Vol. III: Social movement. Petrograd: Ogni [in Russian].

Pypin, A.N. (1916). Russian Freemasonry: 18 and first quarter of the 19 century. Petrograd: Ogni [in Russian].

Ravdin, B.N. & Roginskiy, A.B. (1975). Note from the Decembrist M.N. Novikov ‘On agriculture and manufactures in Russia’ (1816). Osvoboditelnoye dvizheniye v Rossii, 5, 112-143 [in Russian].

Ravita, F. (1889). Thomas Padurra. Kievskaya starina, 26 (9), 727-751 [in Russian].

Ryabinin, I.S. (1915). Polish Freemasonry. In Melgunov, S.P. & Sidorov, N.P. (Eds.). Freemasonry in its past and present. Vol. 2. Petrograd: Zadruga, 226-244 [in Russian].

Ryabinin-Sklyarevsky, O. (1925). Freemasons of the Richelieu Lyceum. Visnyk Odeskoyi komisii kraeznavstva pry VUAN, 2-3: Social-historical section, 134-140 [in Ukrainian].

Semevskiy, V.I. (1908). Decembrists-Masons. Minuvshie gody, II, 1-50; III, 127-170; VI, 379-433 [in Russian].

Serdyukov, I. (1896). Autobiographical note by I.I. Serdyukova. Kievskaya starina, LII, November, 178-224; December, 337-373 [in Russian].

Serkov, A.I. (1997). History of Russian Freemasonry. 1845-1945. St. Peterburg: Izd. im. N. Novikova [in Russian].

Serkov, A.I. (2000). History of Russian Freemasonry of the 19th century. St. Peterburg: Izd. im. N. Novikova [in Russian].

Serkov, A.I. (2001). Russian Freemasonry 1731-2000. Encyclopedic dictionary. Moskva: ROSSPEN [in Russian].

Shchelkov, I. (1890). From the history of Kharkov University. Zhurnal Ministerstva narodnogo prosveshcheniya, 10, 358-385 [in Russian].

Skliarevskyi, O. (1926). Secret Societies in the South in the Era of the Decembrists: Freemasons, Heterians, Philarets and Freethinkers. In Rukh dekabrystiv na Ukraini. Kharkiv: Ukrcentrarchiv, 117-168 [in Ukrainian].

Sklyarevskiy, O. (2009). Description of the private collection of Masonic emblems and ciphers (DAOO. F. P-2. Op. 1. Spr. 109). Pivdennyi arkhiv: istorychni nauky, 30, 214-217 [in Russian].

Slabchenko, M. (1926). Materials for the social and economic history of Ukraine of the 19th century. Vol. 1. Kharkiv [in Ukrainian].

Sokolovskaya, T.O. (1906). To the article about Kyiv and Poltava masons. Russkiy arkhiv. Book III, 609 [in Russian].

Sokolovskaya, T.O. (1915). Revival of Freemasonry under Alexander I. In Melgunov, S.P. & Sidorov, N.P. (Eds.). Freemasonry in its past and present. Vol. 2. Petrograd: Zadruga, 153-202 [in Russian].

Sokolovskaya, T.O. (1916). Phoenix Chapter. The highest secret Masonic rule in Russia (1778-1822). Book 2. Petrograd: Tip. P.P. Soikina [in Russian].

Sokolovskaya, T. (2021). Chapter of Phoenix and other Russian Masonic societies. 1778-1822. Moskva: Izdatelstvo ‘Lomonosov’ [in Russian].

Srebnitsky, I.A. (1881). Lyceum of Prince Bezborodko. In Gimnaziya Vysshikh Nauk i Litsey Kniazya Bezborodko. St. Peterburg, 110-132 [in Russian].

Storozhenko, N.V. (1897). To the portrait of Prince Nikolai Grigorievich Repnin. Kievskaya starina, 12, 473-480 [in Russian].

Subtelnyi, O. (1991). Ukraine: history. Kyiv: Lybid [in Ukrainian].

Tolstoy, L.N. (1938). War and Peace. T. 2. In Tolstoy, L.N. Full collection of works. T. 10. Moskva: Gosizdatelstvo ‘Khudozhestvennaya literatura’ [in Russian].

Yanevskyi, D. (2023). Project ‘Ukraine’. Architects, contractors, workers. Kharkiv: Folio [in Ukrainian].

Zabuzhko, O. (2018). Notre Dame d’Ukraine: Ukrainian woman in the conflict of mythologies. Kyiv: Komora [in Ukrainian].

Zalenski, S. (1908). О masonii w Poisce od roku 1738 do 1822. Krakow [in Polish].

Zięba, A.A. (1999). Sobańska z Potockich Seweryna (1794-1871). In Polski Słownik Biograficzny. Warszawa-Kraków: Polska Akademia Nauk, Polska Akademia Umiejętności. T. XXXIX/3, zeszyt 162, S. 415-417 [in Polish].

Published
15.07.2024
How to Cite
Savchenko, V., & Kudlach, V. (2024). Masonic Movement in Central and Southern Ukraine in the 19th century: Loss of Hopes for Emancipation. Eminak: Scientific Quarterly Journal, (2(46), 186-203. https://doi.org/10.33782/eminak2024.2(46).712
Section
Modern History