Illusion Versus Reality: Ukrainian Experience of World War I

Keywords: illusion, reality, public mood, World War I, society, Right-bank Ukraine, city

Abstract

The purpose of the research paper is to analyze the public attitudes of the inhabitants of Right-bank Ukraine cities during World War I from the perspective of such abstract categories as ‘illusion’ and ‘reality’.

The scientific novelty is in applying a multidisciplinary approach to the study of personal and collective perception of the wartime period of 1914-1917 by the Ukrainian rear area population through the prism of history, philosophy, and social psychology.

Conclusions. During 1914-1917, in the cities of Right-bank Ukraine, a fierce confrontation between the illusory and realistic perception of the events of World War I took place. In the conditions of extreme everyday life, illusions performed various functions, the essence of which reduced itself to attempts to find psychological comfort. The natural human tendency to believe in what one wants to believe, with which the military propaganda of the Russian Empire flirted with varying degrees of success, mitigated the objectively depressing impact of the fact of the outbreak of war on the minds of the population in the summer of 1914. However, typical at the time ‘illusion of a quick solution’, on which the pro-government sentiments were based, was replaced within a year by the ‘illusion of occupation’, causing an unprecedented panic among the urban population.

In the competition between the two controlled and chaotic constructors of illusion – propaganda and rumors – the latter won. The heavy burden of the war inevitably led to disillusionment with the power and the expediency of government policy, and, ultimately, to an ontological crisis in the form of social apathy and ‘erosion of reality’, which testified to its complete capitulation to illusion on the eve of the 1917 revolutionary events. Undermined by the war, critical thinking did not give the general public the ability to distinguish truth from lies. That could not but had a negative impact on society’s ability to perceive reality adequately in the following historical era, when various kinds of social populists effectively used the so-called ‘fictional reality’ to spread their ideas.

References

Adkins, K. (2017). Gossip, Epistemology, and Power. Palgrave Macmillan [in English].

Aksenov, V.B. (2020). Rumors, images, emotions. Mass moods of Russians during the war and revolution (1914-1918). Moskva: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie [in Russian].

Angel, N. (1911). The great illusion: A study of the relation of military power in nations to their economic and social advantage. New York & London: G.P. Putnam’s & Sons [in English].

Aristotle (2022). Metaphysics (Philosophy). Kyiv: Tempora [in Ukrainian].

Becker, J.-J. (2015). Willingly to war. Public response to the outbreak of war. International encyclopedia of the First World War. Retrieved from https://encyclopedia.1914-1918-online.net/article/willingly_to_war_public_response_to_the_outbreak_of_war [in English].

Chykalenko, Ye. (2004). Diary. (1907-1917). In 2 vol.: Documentary and artistic edition. Kyiv: Tempora [in Ukrainian].

Cochet, F. (2008). Home and fighting fronts at the Start of the War: a complicated and ambiguous relationship. In Atkin, N. (Ed.). Daily lives of civilians in wartime twentieth-century Europe. Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, pp. 25-33 [in English].

Cohen, A.J. (2002). Flowers of evil: mass media, child psychology, and the struggle for Russia’s future during the First world war. In Marten, J.A., Coles, R. (Eds.). Children and war: a historical anthology. New York, London: New York University Press [in English].

Davies, O. (2018). A supernatural war: Magic, deviation, and Faith during the First world war. Oxford: Oxford university press [in English].

Degtyarev, S., Gerasimov, T, Gut, J. & Polyakova, L. (2021). World War I and the Collective Visual Illusion: a Case in Zhitomir. Bylye Gody, 16 (3), 1519-1526 [in Russian].

Dehtiarov, S., Romanyuk, I., Gut, J. & Poliakova, L. (2021). Neurasthenia and “Spirit of 1914”: A Causal Relationship (on the Materials of the Right-Bank Ukraine). Bylye Gody, 16 (2), 1000-1007 [in Russian].

Difonzo, N & Bordia, P. (2007). Rumor Psychology. Social And Organizational Approaches. Washington D.C.: American Psychological Association [in English].

Dijkstra, N. & Fleming, S.M. (2023). Subjective signal strength distinguishes reality from imagination. Nature Communications, 14, 1627. DOI: 10.1038/s41467-023-37322-1 [in English].

Doroshenko, D. (1969). My memories of the recent past. 1914-1920. Miunkhen: Ukrainske vydavnytstvo [in Ukrainian].

Drahomanov, M. (1906). Paradise and progress. Kyiv: Drukarnia P. Barskoho [in Ukrainian].

Dzhumyha, Ye. (2013). Rumors as a mental component of everyday life of Odessa residents during the First World War (1914-1917). Naukovi pratsi istorychnoho fakultetu Zaporizkoho natsionalnoho universytetu, 35, 98-101 [in Ukrainian].

Etkind, A. (1997). Discourse and revolution: Grigory Rasputin. Revue des Études Slaves Année, 69 (1-2), 223-248 [in Russian].

Freud, S. (1961). The future on an illusion. New York: Norton & Company [in English].

Herwig, H. (2002). Germany and the ‘Short-War’ Illusion: Toward a New Interpretation? The Journal of Military History, 66 (3), 681-693 [in English].

Koliada, I., Gerasymov, T. & Romaniuk, I. (2023). The First World War and Ukrainian society: a historical retrospective and modern reflections. Naukovi pratsi Kamianets-Podilskoho natsionalnoho universytetu imeni Ivana Ohiienka: istorychni nauky, 39, 159-175 [in Ukrainian].

Kutsyk, R. (2017). Caricature as a special mechanism of information propaganda on the territory of the Ukrainian provinces of the South-West Region in 1914-1917. Naukovi pratsi istorychnoho fakultetu Zaporizkoho natsionalnoho universytetu, 47, 86-91 [in English].

Kutsyk, R. (2017). Reception of the informational influence of the Russian imperial power on the population of the Kyiv, Podil and Volyn provinces in 1914-1917. Kyivski istorychni studii, 1 (4), 82-87 [in Ukrainian].

Kutsyk, R. (2022). Visualization of the Events of the First World War in the Press: Based on the Materials of the Kyiv Newspapers (1914-1917). Storinky istorii, 5, 88-110 [in Ukrainian].

Lazerowitz, M. (1967). Philosophy and illusion. Crítica: Revista Hispanoamericana de Filosofía, 1 (2), 55-82 [in English].

Levitskij, V.M. (1915). Street children and war. Deti i vojna: sbornik statej. Kiev: Izdanie Kievskogo Frebelevskogo Obshestva [in Russian].

Lyfar, S. (2007). Memories of Icarus. Kyiv: Univ. vyd-vo Pulsary [in Ukrainian].

Medyakov, A. (2018). Propaganda at home (Russian Empire). International encyclopedia of the First World War. Retrieved from https://encyclopedia.1914-1918-online.net/article/propaganda_at_home_russian_empire [in English].

Navari, C. (1989). The great illusion revisited: the international theory of Norman Angell. Review of International Studies, 15 (4), 341-358 [in English].

Reient, O. & Serdiuk, O. (2004). The First World War and Ukraine. Kyiv: Heneza [in Ukrainian].

Ringmar, E. (2018). “The spirit of 1914”: A redefinition and a defence. War in History, 25 (1), 26-47 [in English].

Ropolyi, L. (2016). Virtuallity and reality – toward a representation ontology. Philosophies, 1, 40-54. Retrieved from https://www.mdpi.com/2409-9287/1/1/40 [in English].

Sajn-Vitgenshtejn, E.N. (1986). Diary 1914-1918. Paris: YMCA-press [in Russian].

Sartre, J.-P. (1948). The philosophy of imagination. New-York: Philosophical library [in English].

Schopenhauer, A. (2014). The World as Will and Representation: Vol. 1. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press [in English].

Schumaker, Jh. (2020). Reality and unreality: the growing power of the lie. Retrieved from https://www.laprogressive.com/elections/reality-and-unreality [in English].

Semenova, E.Yu. (2011). Patriotic and anti-patriotic sentiments of the Volga region townspeople during the First World War (1914 – early 1918). Sovremennye problemy nauki i obrazovaniya, 5. Retrieved from https://www.science-education.ru/ru/article/view?id=4905 [in Russian].

Sepp, A. & Vandevoorde, H. (2020). Reality of the extraordinary. Wartime diary writing. Revue belge de Philologie et d’Histoire, 98, 579-592 [in English].

Shovkova, O.D. (2018). Types of illusion of thinking in collective psychology. Naukovi zapysky Natsionalnoho universytetu «Ostrozka akademiia». Seriia: Psykholohiia, 7, 33-39 [in Ukrainian].

Shulgin, V.V. (2002). The Last Eyewitness: Memoirs. Essays. Dreams. Moskva: OLMA-PRESS Zvyozdnyj mir [in Russian].

Stuart, P. & Strathern, A. (2004). Witchcraft, Sorcery, Rumors, and Gossip. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press [in English].

Suhova, O.L. (2014). Social moods and mass social behavior of provincial society during the First World War. XX vek i Rossiya: obshestvo, reformy, revolyucii, 2, 105-127 [in Russian].

Tamas, S. & Zsolt, S. (2021). The impact of the first world war on peasant society. Ethnographia, 132 (1), 89-116 [in English].

Tard, G. (2018). Public opinion and the crowd. Moskva: Lenand [in Russian].

Tolstoj, A.N. (1989). Around Volyn. In Pervaya mirovaya. Moskva: Molodaya gvardiya, pp. 370-374 [in Russian].

Vernadskyi, V. (2012). Volodymyr Ivanovych Vernadskyi. Correspondence with Ukrainian scientists. Book 2. Kyiv [in Ukrainian].

Wouk, H. (1992). War and remembrance. Boston: Little, Brown and Company [in English].

Yacobi, B.G. (2013). The human dilemma: life between illusion and reality. Journal of Philosophy of Life, 3 (3), 202-211 [in English].

Published
15.10.2024
How to Cite
Gerasymov, T., & Romanyuk, I. (2024). Illusion Versus Reality: Ukrainian Experience of World War I. Eminak: Scientific Quarterly Journal, (3(47), 130-146. https://doi.org/10.33782/eminak2024.3(47).732
Section
Modern History