Rape as a Form of Sexual Violence During the Holocaust (Evidence From General District Volyn-Podillia)
Abstract
The purpose of the paper is to uncover rape as the most criminal form of sexual violence directed at Jewish women during the Holocaust (in the example of the General District Volyn-Podillia).
The scientific novelty of the paper is in the fact that rape as sexual violence directed at Jewish women during the Holocaust in a single territory (Volyn and Podillia) has been singled out and analyzed for the first time in a separate study.
The research methodology is based on the principles of scientism, historicism, objectivity, problematic-historical, and searching methods, as well as methods of analysis and systematization. The oral history method has become important in the study.
Conclusions. Rape, in the context of sexual violence, was a common practice during the Holocaust. Such crimes were committed by German soldiers, the Gestapo and other occupiers, their minions – collaborators, the Ukrainian police, as well as civilians, neighbors, rescuers, and ‘ordinary men’. Despite the prohibition of sexual relations between Germans and Jewish women, that rule was not enforced either in Germany or in the territories it occupied. The waves of sexual violence in the analyzed territories of Volyn and Podillia could be considered the initial period of the occupation, staying in the ghetto, and ‘Final Solution to the Jewish Question’, as well as the period of hiding. The conclusions of the study show that the committed sexual crimes depended more on mercantile reasons, satisfying the sexual needs of the rapists than on their ideological/anti-Semite or political preferences.
Enforcers of the Ukrainian police during their service in the civil administration of the Reichskommissariat Ukraine, who, by virtue of their official duties, were most often in contact with Jews and had the opportunity to commit violence against them, were widely involved in the crimes committed. Gang rapes were frequent, indicating the impact of brutalization and violence during the war, and the perpetrators’ belief that they would not be punished. Sometimes after rape, women were tried to be killed in order to conceal the traces of the crimes.
Jewish women had a ghost of a chance of defending themselves. They succeeded only in some cases. Sexual violence affected not only women and girls but also men, for whom it was an act of humiliation, a manifestation of their inability to protect women.
Funding. This project has received funding through the EURIZON project, which is funded by the European Union under grant agreement No. 871072. Also, this study was carried out thanks to access to sources from the collection of ‘Visual History and Education’ of the Shoah Foundation (University of Southern California, USA) and oral testimonies of Yahad-In unum (Paris, France).
References
Anapolskyi, N. (2000). Thanks to good people – ukrainians, poles – we survived death… In Zabarko, B. (Ed. & Comp.). Zhyvymi ostalis tolko my: svidetelstva i dokumenty. Kyiv: Zadruha, pp. 30-45 [in Russian].
Browning, Chr. (2001). Ordinary Men. London: Penguin Books [in English].
Burds, J. (2015). Sexual violence in Europe during World War II (1939-1945). In Hrinchenko, H., Kobchenko, K. & Kis, O. (Eds.). Zhinky Tsentralnoi ta Skhidnoi Yevropy u Druhii svitovii viini: henderna spetsyfika dosvidu v chasy ekstremalnoho nasylstva. Kyiv: TOV «ART KNYHA», pp. 278-306 [in Ukrainian].
Dean, M. (Ed.). (2012). Encyclopedia of Camps and Ghettos, 1933-1945: Ghettos in German-Occupied Eastern Europe. Vol. 2. Washington: Indiana University Press [in English].
Diment, M. (2016). A lonely exile. A diary about Svyniukhy and the ghetto in Lokachi. Kyiv: UTsVIH [in Ukrainian].
Jones, A. (2019). Genocide: An Introduction to Global History. Kyiv: DUKh I LITERA [in Ukrainian].
Havryshko, M. (2019). Rape in hiding places: sexual violence during the Holocaust in Ukraine. Holokost i suchasnist: studiyi v Ukraini i sviti, 1 (17), 10-30 [in Ukrainian].
Havryshko, M. (2020). Women in the anti-Jewish pogroms of the summer of 1941 in Galicia: victims, perpetrators and rescuers. In Pater, I. (Ed.) & Romaniuk, M. (Comp.). Mizhnatsionalni vidnosyny v Ukraini u XX – na pochatku XXI st. Zakhidni zemli. Lviv, 345-403 [in Ukrainian].
Havryshko, M. (2020, May 18). Sexual Violence in the Holocaust: Perspectives from Ghettos and Camps in Ukraine. Heinrich Böll Stiftung. Retrieved from https://ua.boell.org/en/2020/05/18/sexual-violence-holocaust-perspectives-ghettos-and-camps-ukraine [in English].
Havryshko, M. (2021). Listening to Women’s Voices: Jewish Rape Survivors’ Testimonies in Soviet War Crimes Trials. In Nešťáková, D., Grosse-Sommer, K. & Klacsmann, B. (Eds.). If this is a Woman. Studies on Women and Gender in the Holocaust. Boston: Academic Studies Press, pp. 221-242 [in English].
Havryshko, M. (2023). Rape on Trial: Criminal Justice Actors in 1940s Soviet Ukraine and Sexual Violence during the Holocaust. In Wylegała, A., Rutar, S. & Łukianow, M. (Eds.). No Neighbours’ Land: Postwar Europe in a New Comparative Perspective. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 205-227. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-10857-0_9 [in English].
Hinda, V. (2022). Sex and the German-Soviet War. Kyiv: Arii [in Ukrainian].
Hon, M. & Ivchyk, N. (2016). Women during the Holocaust: fates, behavior and gender (in)equalities. Holokost i suchasnist: studiyi v Ukraini i sviti, 1 (14), 9-49 [in Ukrainian].
Hon, M. & Ivchyk, N. (2022). The female ‘face’ of the Holocaust: the gender aspect of the genocide of the Jews in Ukraine (1941-1944). Problemy istorii Holokostu: ukrainskyi vymir, 14, 10-40. DOI: https://doi.org/10.33124/hsuf.2022.14.01 [in Ukrainian].
Ivchyk, N. (2022). Gender-motivated violence during the Holocaust. In Suspilno-politychni ta istorychni aspekty rozvytku suchasnoi yevreiskoi hromady Ukrainy: yevropeiskyi kontekst. Kyiv: IPiEnD im. I.F. Kurasa NAN Ukrainy, pp. 329-344 [in Ukrainian].
Klymenko, O. & Tkachov, S. (2012). Ukrainians in the police in the Reichskommissariat ‘Ukraine’: the German occupation regime in Kremenets region in 1941-1944. Kharkiv: Ranok NP [in Ukrainian].
Kruhlov, A. (2010). Pogroms in Eastern Galicia in the summer of 1941: organizers, participants, scope and consequences. Problemy istorii Holokostu, 5, 56-73 [in Ukrainian].
Lower, W. (2011). Pogroms, mob violence and genocidein western Ukraine, summer 1941: varied histories, explanations and comparisons. Journal of Genocide Research, 13 (3), 217-246 [in English].
McBride, J. (2022). The Tuchyn Pogrom: The Names and Faces Behind the Violence, Summer 1941. Holocaust and Genocide Studies, 36 (3), 315-333. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/hgs/dcac041 [in English].
Mędykowski, W. (2012). W cieniugigantów: Pogromy 1941 roku w byłej sowieckiej strefie okupacyjnej: kontekst historyczny, społeczny i kulturowy [In the Shadow of Giants: The 1941 Pogroms in the Former Soviet Occupation Zone: Historical, Social and Cultural Context]. Warszawa: Instytut Studiów Politycznych PAN [in Polish].
Miulkhoizer, R. (2015). An undeniable crime. Sexual violence by German soldiers during the ‘War of Annihilation’ in the Soviet Union in 1941-1945. In Hrinchenko, H., Kobchenko, K. & Kis, O. (Eds.). Zhinky Tsentralnoi ta Skhidnoi Yevropy u Druhii svitovii viini: henderna spetsyfika dosvidu v chasy ekstremalnoho nasylstva. Kyiv: TOV «ART KNYHA», pp. 270-277 [in Ukrainian].
Mühlhäuser, R. (2021). Sex and the Nazi Soldier: Violent, Commercial and Consensual Encounters during the War in the Soviet Union, 1941-45. Edinburgh University Press [in English].
Muzychenko, V. (2021). Volodymyr the Jew. History and tragedy of the Jewish community of Volodymyr-Volynskyi. Novovolynsk: Format [in Ukrainian].
Mykhalchuk, R. (2022). “I Was Worse Than a Dog and All The Time I Asked Why”: the Situation of Jews in Mizoch During the Holocaust. Problemy istorii Holokostu: ukrainskyi vymir, 14, 58-100. DOI: https://doi.org/10.33124/hsuf.2022.14.03 [in Ukrainian].
Mykhalchuk, R. (2022). Death and survival during the Holocaust: the terrain of modern Rivne region. Rivne: Volynski oberehy [in Ukrainian].
Mykhalchuk, R. (2022). Establishment and Functioning of Rivne Ghetto. Intermarum: istoriia, polityka, kultura, 10, 73-91. DOI: https://doi.org/10.35433/history.112031%20 [in Ukrainian].
Mykolaichuk, N. (Comp.). (2011). Ostroghets from ancient times to the present. Lutsk: PrAT «Volynska oblasna drukarnia» [in Ukrainian].
Podolskyi, A. (2015). Jewish women of Ukraine during the Holocaust and Nazi occupation (1941-1944): attempts to research the tragic fate. In Hrinchenko, H., Kobchenko, K. & Kis, O. (Eds.). Zhinky Tsentralnoi ta Skhidnoi Yevropy u Druhii svitovii viini: henderna spetsyfika dosvidu v chasy ekstremalnoho nasylstva. Kyiv: TOV «ART KNYHA», pp. 219-230 [in Ukrainian].
Spector, S. (1990). The Holocaust of Volhynian Jewry, 1941-1944. Jerusalem: Yad Vashem [in English].
Struve, K. (2022). German Power, Ukrainian nationalism, violence against Jews: the summer of 1941 in Western Ukraine. Kyiv: DUKh I LITERA [in Ukrainian].
Vasyliev, V., Lysenko, O., Markova, S., Podkur, R., Khoptiar, A. & Khoptiar, Yu. (Comps.). (2022). Violence against the civilian population. Khmelnytskyi region. Documents of state security agencies. 1941-1944. Kyiv: Vydavets V. Zakharenko [in Ukrainian].
Zbikowski, A. (1993). Local Anti-Jewish pogroms in the Occuped Territories of Eastern Poland, June–July 1941. In Dobroszycki, L. & Gurock, J. (Eds.). The Holocaust in the Soviet Union: studies and sources on the destruction of the Jews in the Nazi-occupied Territories of the USSR. 1941-1945. NY & London: M.E. Sharpe, pp. 173-179 [in English].

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.